Green Cheek Beer Company’s And Just Like That, As Mysteriously As He Had Arrived, He Was Gone is a 5.6% Pale Ale hopped with Mosaic, El Dorado, Galaxy, and Idaho 7. Designed and brewed by head brewer Mitch on his last day with the brewery, it celebrates more than three years of work, from keg washer in 2018 to head brewer. The brewery describes a lean pale ale that is light on bitterness and heavy on hoppy aromatics and flavor. Untappd lists it as an American Pale Ale, and Mitch’s own tasting notes for the recipe were lemon zest, fruity pebbles, lychee, and cantaloupe, a lineup the Mosaic, El Dorado, Galaxy, and Idaho 7 blend is well suited to deliver.
Appearance
The beer is clean and bright in the glass.
Aroma
Bright, hoppy aromatics set the tone.
Tasting Notes
Lemon zest comes up front, followed by slightly dry, biscuity malt on the finish and a hint of lingering resin. Clean, bright, and hoppy overall. The four-hop blend of Mosaic, El Dorado, Galaxy, and Idaho 7 is kept in check by the light bitterness the brewery was aiming for, so the hop flavor stays the focus.




Mouthfeel & Drinkability
The finish is slightly dry with a biscuity malt note, and a trace of resin lingers. At 5.6% ABV it is a lean, crushable pale that the reviewer felt was proof Green Cheek makes some of the best crushers around.
Food Pairings
The lemon zest, biscuity malt, and lingering resin suit light, fresh dishes. Try it with:
- Lemon-herb roasted chicken – Mirrors the lemon zest.
- Margherita flatbread – Biscuity crust suits the malt note.
- Cantaloupe and mint salad – Echoes the cantaloupe and lychee-like fruit the brewer describes.
- Grilled fish tacos – Light and crisp for a crushable pairing.
Final Notes
And Just Like That, As Mysteriously As He Had Arrived, He Was Gone is a clean, lemony Pale Ale from Green Cheek Beer Company that earns its 4.55/5 as a farewell toast to a brewer. A fitting send-off.
Have you tried this one? Let us know your thoughts.

