Alvarado Street Brewery’s Midnight Supreme proves winter stout doesn’t have to be a booze-and-roast monster — this one is decadent, balanced, and tremendously drinkable, with deep folds of rich vanilla and luxurious cacao.
Appearance
Midnight Supreme pours a deep brown hue topped with a frothy, long-lasting, light brown head.
Aroma
A nice vanilla-y nose leads the way, hinting at the cacao and dark fruit character to come.
Tasting Notes
More vanilla notes show up front, subtle dark fruit hides underneath, and a cocoa finish rounds things out with minimal booziness.



Mouthfeel & Drinkability
The mellow roast character holds on for a long, satisfying finish, while minimal booziness keeps this one dangerously drinkable for a stout of its depth.
Food Pairings
The vanilla, cacao, and dark fruit character make this a great match for rich desserts. Try it with:
- Vanilla bean crème brûlée – A direct echo of the beer’s dominant vanilla notes.
- Dark chocolate torte – Complements the beer’s luxurious cacao character.
- Mixed dark berry compote – Ties in the beer’s subtle dark fruit notes.
- Espresso panna cotta – A rich match for the beer’s mellow roast finish.
Final Notes
Midnight Supreme is a decadent yet balanced stout from Alvarado Street Brewery that earns its 4.25/5 by delivering vanilla and cacao without tipping into an overwhelming boozy mess. Stout reigns supreme, indeed.
Let us know if you’ve had this one and what you thought.

